WhichEV.Net
  • Buying Advice
  • EV Answers
  • Features
  • News
    • All
    • Charging
    • Commercial Vehicles
    • Consumer Vehicles
    • Cool Car Tech
    • Curiosities
    • Design
    • Energy
    • Environment
    • Industry
    • Legal
    • Market
    • Motorsport
    • Public Sector
    • Records
    • Rumours
    • Safety
    • Sharing
    • Solar

    Volvo introduces the EX30 as the next step in sustainability

    Is Sunak considering a special £625 a year road tax for EVs?

    VW resets software programme – autonomous delayed by 4 years

    Can solar panels between rail tracks generate significant power?

    eBike bargains and sunshine? Time to get out there

    Stellantis urges UK Government to renegotiate Brexit

    Trending Tags

  • Reviews
No Result
View All Result
WhichEV.Net
  • Buying Advice
  • EV Answers
  • Features
  • News
    • All
    • Charging
    • Commercial Vehicles
    • Consumer Vehicles
    • Cool Car Tech
    • Curiosities
    • Design
    • Energy
    • Environment
    • Industry
    • Legal
    • Market
    • Motorsport
    • Public Sector
    • Records
    • Rumours
    • Safety
    • Sharing
    • Solar

    Volvo introduces the EX30 as the next step in sustainability

    Is Sunak considering a special £625 a year road tax for EVs?

    VW resets software programme – autonomous delayed by 4 years

    Can solar panels between rail tracks generate significant power?

    eBike bargains and sunshine? Time to get out there

    Stellantis urges UK Government to renegotiate Brexit

    Trending Tags

  • Reviews
No Result
View All Result
WhichEV.Net
No Result
View All Result
Home News Legal Legislation

Has Paris overwhelmingly voted to ban e-scoooters?

WhichEV asks Ross Ringham - electric mobility expert

Staff Writer by Staff Writer
10th April 2023
in Legislation, News, Scooters
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

With all of the world’s major economies working hard to reduce their carbon footprint, last week’s news that Paris had ‘overwhelmingly voted to ban e-scooters’ took many by surprise. One voice of reason analysed the story, breaking down the fiction to reveal the facts. The voice belongs to Ross Ringham, Managing Director of Spacesuit Media – a company specialising in photography and film making around electric mobility and electric racing events. This is his take on Parisian proceedings.

“Last week’s reporting on this story, felt sloppy and misleading”, says Ringham. So what did actually happen and what does it mean? Here's a six-point breakdown on the Parisian vote by Ringham:-

  1. Was the vote legally binding?
    The mayor of Paris conducted an opinion poll in Paris on the future of rental e-scooters.
    The results hold no water, legally. It remains the mayor's decision whether or not to renew the city's shared e-scooter programme when it reaches the end of its contract later this summer
  2. So is Paris banning e-scooters?
    Paris is not banning e-scooters.
    The mayor is likely to simply not renew contracts for shared e-scooter providers, and seems perfectly content to allow personal e-scooters (which already are responsible for hundreds of thousands of journeys) to flourish
  3. Did enough people vote for it to be significant?
    Despite not being a legal vote, and despite the legal age to ride e-scooters being just 12 in France, opinions could only be cast by those of electoral voting age (18+), carrying their official ID, at quasi-official voting booths.
    A mere 21 booths were set up around the city. There was no digital access. Voting options were binary: yes or no. This limited and limiting set-up favours an older demographic, and it's likely no coincidence that it's those older residents who are both more likely to turn out for a paper vote and more likely to dislike e-scooters. A tiny percentage of the city's voters (less than 8%) actually bothered – surely the very definition of the ‘noisy minority’
  4. Would the ban help reduce street clutter?
    Will discontinuing shared e-scooters solve the biggest subjects of discontent among that minority – poor parking and inconsiderate riding?
    No. While the move may reduce street clutter from parked e-scooters, if anything it will lead to an explosion in cheaply-made, cheaply-bought personal e-scooters being ridden by 14-year-olds. Those internet-sourced machines will likely arrive without speed limiters, without adequate lighting, and painted in dark colours. It's a situation that could quickly become a nightmare for visually impaired people and other vulnerable groups
  5. How much would the ban cost Paris?
    In the meantime, if the mayor does decide to close up shop for shared e-scooters, the city purse will forgo nearly €1m in fees collected from the three shared e-scooter providers, and the mayor will be directly responsible for putting some 800 people out of work
  6. Does this situation mean all of Europe is likely to ban e-scooters?
    No. Does it mean shared e-scooter companies are the victims of political posturing of a mayor playing to a safe gallery?
    Partly, yes. However, the shared e-scooter industry does bear some culpability for a Silicon Valley-like history of over-promising and under-delivering (on safety tech, on safety processes, on environmental credentials, on community communication and on low-income support, in particular)

Ringham doubts we have seen the end of shared e-scooters in Paris, but he does believe that the financial/operating model will undergo change – with companies like Velib likely to do well.

Having used them across Germany, Spain, France and other countries, WhichEV feels that e-scooters need to form part of the core for future inner-city transport. Sure, the legislation needs to be looked at, but believing that cars are a good thing and that e-scooters are too dangerous – is just not going to stand up to scrutiny.

Here in the UK, the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (ROSPA), has stated that e-scooters are demonstrably five times safer than bicycles. Let along cars, trucks or buses.

Tags: e-scootersParis
Previous Post

Essex gets initial grant of £236,000 for public chargers

Next Post

Tesla applies additional discounts to high end models

Staff Writer

Staff Writer

Experienced writers from the automobile and technology sectors - working with the in-house EV editorial team to deliver top quality, independent content in a timely fashion.

Related Posts

Volvo introduces the EX30 as the next step in sustainability

25th May 2023

Is Sunak considering a special £625 a year road tax for EVs?

24th May 2023

VW resets software programme – autonomous delayed by 4 years

23rd May 2023

Can solar panels between rail tracks generate significant power?

22nd May 2023
Next Post

Tesla applies additional discounts to high end models

Review Finder

Latest News

Volvo introduces the EX30 as the next step in sustainability

25th May 2023

Is Sunak considering a special £625 a year road tax for EVs?

24th May 2023

VW resets software programme – autonomous delayed by 4 years

23rd May 2023

Trending

  • WhichEV Awards 2023: The Year’s Best EVs

    2789 shares
    Share 1116 Tweet 697
  • Future electric cars: Best upcoming electric cars, SUVs and pickup trucks – 2021 UPDATE!

    1410 shares
    Share 580 Tweet 346
  • How to turn your favourite classic car into an EV

    1340 shares
    Share 553 Tweet 328
  • Octopus Electric Vehicles launches an all-in-one EV bundle

    1298 shares
    Share 519 Tweet 325
  • What makes an EV charging station accessible for people with disabilities?

    1228 shares
    Share 491 Tweet 307
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact the WhichEV team today

© 2022 WhichEV. Limited - All of the independent news and expert reviews you need in one publication.

No Result
View All Result
  • Buying Advice
  • EV Answers
  • Features
  • News
  • Reviews

© 2022 WhichEV. Limited - All of the independent news and expert reviews you need in one publication.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.